Retention is the part of your money that you earn but do not receive. On a £60,000 subcontract with a 5% retention, £3,000 stays with the contractor after you have done the work, and you may wait months or even a year or more to see it. For a small firm, that sum can be the difference between a comfortable quarter and a stressful one. Understanding how retention works, when it should be released and what you can do if it is withheld puts you in a far better position than simply hoping it turns up.
What retention is and why it exists
Retention is a percentage of each payment, or of the overall contract sum, that the paying party holds back as security. The idea is that if defects appear or work is left unfinished, the client or main contractor has money in hand to put things right without chasing anyone. It also gives the person doing the work a reason to come back and fix problems promptly.
The percentage is set by the contract, not by law. Rates of around 3% to 5% are commonly seen in the industry, but there is no universal figure, and the rate on your job could be higher or lower. Some small domestic jobs have no retention at all, while larger commercial subcontracts nearly always do. If it is not written into your agreement, a contractor generally has no automatic right to withhold it, so the contract wording matters.
How retention is usually held back and released
On most commercial contracts, retention is deducted from interim payments as the work progresses. When the building reaches practical completion, meaning it is essentially finished and can be used for its intended purpose, a portion is typically released. The remainder is released once a defects liability period has ended and any defects have been put right.
A common arrangement is that half the retention is released at practical completion and the other half at the end of a defects period lasting somewhere between six and twelve months, although the length varies and some contracts run longer. Using the earlier example, a £3,000 retention would mean around £1,500 coming back at practical completion and the rest following after the defects period, provided everything has been dealt with.
Subcontractors and the main contract timetable
This is where tradespeople often get caught out. A subcontractor may finish its own work in the first month of a project that runs for two years. Unless the subcontract says otherwise, the first half of the retention may not be released until the whole project reaches practical completion, which could be a long way off. Some subcontracts provide for release when your own package is complete, or when a section of the works is finished, and it is worth checking which applies before you sign.
What the contract should tell you
Read the retention clause carefully before starting work, because several details affect your cash flow:
- The percentage withheld and whether it applies to the whole contract value or only to certain payments
- When the first release is due and what triggers it, such as practical completion of the whole project, a section or your own works
- How long the defects period lasts and who decides when it has ended
- Whether the retention is held in a separate account or on trust, and whether you can ask for confirmation
- How and when you should apply for release
Some standard forms of contract provide for retention to be held on trust for the benefit of the person it was deducted from, which gives some protection if the paying party becomes insolvent. In practice this depends on the exact contract terms, and whether the money has genuinely been set aside. Do not assume protection exists unless the contract says so and you have asked for evidence.
Retention and the Construction Act
Where the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 applies, which generally means commercial construction contracts rather than work for a homeowner on their own home, retention release is treated as a sum due under the contract like any other. The usual rules on notices apply. If the paying party intends to withhold some or all of a release, it should issue the correct notices within the timescales set by the contract or the Act’s default provisions.
A contractor cannot generally avoid paying retention simply by saying it has not yet been paid itself by the client. The Act restricts pay-when-paid clauses, although exceptions exist, including where the paying party’s own customer is insolvent. If a contract appears to say that you only get your retention when the contractor gets theirs, take advice, because such a clause may not be enforceable in the way it is written.
If retention is wrongly withheld on a contract covered by the Act, you can refer the dispute to adjudication, which usually leads to a decision within weeks rather than months. The practicalities and cost are worth weighing against the sum involved.
When retention goes wrong
Defects and set-off
The most common reason for withholding retention is a genuine or alleged defect. If a contractor claims work is defective, you will usually be expected to return and put it right, or to agree a sensible deduction. Keep dated photographs, completion certificates, test records and sign-off documents, because they help show that your work met the specification at handover. If you are asked to return to fix something, do it promptly and get written confirmation that the matter is closed.
A contractor cannot normally hold back more than the value of a genuine claim, and it should be able to explain how it has calculated the amount. Vague statements that “we’re holding your retention for now” without a reason are worth challenging politely in writing.
Insolvency
If the person holding your retention becomes insolvent, the outcome depends on how it was held. If the money was genuinely held on trust in a separate account, you may have a claim against that fund. If it was not, you may be an unsecured creditor and could receive only a fraction of what you are owed, or nothing. This is the strongest reason to find out who you are working for before agreeing terms, and to pursue any retention that falls due promptly rather than leaving it for later.
Negotiating retention before you sign
Retention terms are not always set in stone. Small businesses sometimes feel they have no room to negotiate, but a few sensible requests are often considered, particularly where you are a regular supplier or the contractor wants you for the job:
- A lower percentage, or a cap on the total retention
- Release of the first half on completion of your own works rather than the whole project
- A shorter defects period for your package
- A retention bond or other security in place of cash retention, where the contractor is willing to accept it
- A clear written process for applying for release
Asking costs nothing, and the contractor can only say no. Checking how other trades have fared with the same company before agreeing terms is just as useful, and a guide on how Plumbers Find Trusted Tradespeople through recommendations explains one way to hear about a contractor’s payment record before you commit.
Keeping track of what you are owed
Retention is easy to forget because it sits quietly in the background of a job for months. Record the amount withheld on every payment, keep a running total for each contract, and note the likely release dates in your diary. When practical completion is reached, ask for a written confirmation of the date and the amount due, and invoice for the release promptly if the contract requires you to apply for it.
If a release date passes without payment, chase it in writing straight away, quoting the clause that sets the due date. Contracts and legal time limits both matter here. For most simple contract debts in England and Wales you have six years to bring a claim, but acting within weeks gives you a much better chance of settling it informally. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own rules, so check the position where you work.
A practical next step
Before accepting your next subcontract, find the retention clause and write down three things: the percentage, the trigger for the first release and the length of the defects period. Then work out what that means in pounds on the job in front of you and whether your cash flow can cope with waiting for it. If you are building up your client base, a construction platform for plumbers can help you reach contractors and developers beyond your usual circle, which gives you more choice over whose terms you agree to. For a large or complicated contract, a short consultation with a solicitor or your trade body before signing costs far less than a retention dispute afterwards.

